Most of the form is simple. Two or three boxes are not, and they decide what the bank reports about the company and its owners. This article explains what those boxes mean and where companies go wrong. We prepare and review these forms for UAE companies: FATCA and CRS forms, preparation and review.
Why your bank is asking
The bank is not being difficult. Under the UAE rules, the bank must obtain a self-certification from the account holder to establish its status. The bank reports to the UAE authorities each year, and the authorities pass the information on. Two separate systems sit behind the one form.
FATCA in one minute
FATCA is a USA law passed in 2010. It makes financial institutions outside the USA report accounts held by USA taxpayers, and accounts held by foreign companies in which USA taxpayers hold a substantial ownership interest. The UAE signed an agreement with the USA on 17 June 2015, so UAE banks report through the UAE Ministry of Finance.
CRS in one minute
CRS is the Common Reporting Standard, written by the OECD. It does the same job for other countries. The bank records where the company is resident for tax, and for some companies, where the people behind it are resident for tax. Under the UAE rules, CRS covers countries other than the USA. The USA is covered by FATCA.
FATCA and CRS side by side
| FATCA | CRS | |
|---|---|---|
| Who wrote it | The USA | The OECD |
| What the bank looks for | USA persons | Tax residents of other countries |
| Form | W-8BEN-E or W-9, or the bank's own form | The bank's self-certification form |
| Word for an ordinary company | NFFE, a non-financial foreign entity | NFE, a non-financial entity |
| The key question | Active or Passive | Active or Passive |
Which form the bank means
A company that is not a USA company is asked for Form W-8BEN-E. A USA person, including a USA citizen, a USA resident or a company formed in the USA, is asked for Form W-9. Many UAE banks use their own form in place of the W-8BEN-E and add the CRS questions to it. The form goes to the bank. It is never sent to the IRS.
Active or Passive
For an ordinary company this is the box that matters. The main test is the same idea under both systems: a company is Active when less than 50% of last year's gross income was passive income, and less than 50% of its assets were held to produce passive income. Passive income includes dividends, interest, rents, royalties and annuities.
A trading company, a contractor or a consultancy with normal sales is usually Active. A company that only holds shares, property or deposits is usually Passive.
Why it is not a tick-box answer
The test reads like simple arithmetic. In practice these are the points where companies go wrong:
- Both halves must pass. A company with busy trading income but a balance sheet full of deposits and investments can fail on its assets.
- The rules decide what is passive, not the owner. They carry their own list of passive income, and it is wider than most owners expect.
- It is last year's answer. The test uses the last calendar year, so a company can be Active one year and Passive the next.
- There are other routes to Active. The 50% test is only one of several, and some holding and group companies qualify another way.
- A managed portfolio can change everything. The company may not be Active or Passive at all. It may be a financial institution.
- Passive means the owners are named. The people who control the company must be identified correctly, each with their own tax residence.
What Passive means in practice
Passive is not a penalty and not a bad mark. It means the bank looks through the company to the people who control it.
- Under CRS, the bank asks for a controlling person form for each of them. If any controlling person is tax resident in a country the UAE reports to, the account is reported.
- Under FATCA, a Passive company must either state that it has no substantial USA owners or controlling USA persons, or give the name, address and USA tax number of each one.
So the honest answer for a holding company is often "Passive, and here are the owners". Ticking Active to avoid the owner questions is the mistake that causes trouble later.
When an investment company is a financial institution
This is the part owners rarely expect. A company whose income comes mainly from investing or trading in financial assets, and which is managed by a bank, a custodian or an investment manager, can be an "investment entity". An investment entity is a financial institution, not a Passive company.
The USA rules and the UAE rules agree on this point. The IRS instructions for Form W-8BEN-E say that a company which would be Passive, but is managed by certain types of financial institutions, should not tick the Passive box, because it is treated as a financial institution. The UAE Ministry of Finance guidance on CRS has the same test, and sets "mainly" at 50% or more of gross income.
Why it matters: a financial institution has its own status on the form and may have reporting duties of its own. It may also need a GIIN. A GIIN, a global intermediary identification number, is the registration number the IRS gives to a financial institution that registers with it. Whether a company is "managed by" a financial institution depends on its agreement with the bank or manager. This is the question we look at first for any family holding company with a managed portfolio.
Getting it wrong
- In the UAE, an account holder or controlling person who gives a self-certification with information they knew, or should have known, was wrong can be fined AED 20,000.
- Form W-8BEN-E is signed under penalties of perjury.
- If something changes and makes your W-8BEN-E wrong, you must tell the bank within 30 days.
- A W-8BEN-E generally stays valid until the end of the third calendar year after you sign it, unless something changes sooner.
Before you sign
The company signs the form as its own declaration, so the answer has to be one it can stand behind. Send us the bank's form, the trade license, the ownership chart and the latest financial statements. We prepare the forms for you, or review the ones already filled in, and give you a one-page note that explains the classification. FATCA and CRS forms, preparation and review.
We also prepare and sign USA tax returns in Dubai, for individuals and companies in the UAE, the GCC, Europe and elsewhere: USA tax for individuals, USA business tax.
In short
- One form, two systems: FATCA for the USA, CRS for other countries.
- The key box is Active or Passive, and it rests on last year's income and assets.
- Passive means the bank asks about the owners. It is not a penalty.
- A company with a portfolio managed by a bank may be a financial institution, not a Passive company.
- You sign the form. Have it prepared or checked before you do.
Where these rules are written
- IRS, Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E: who uses the form, who it is given to, Form W-9 for USA persons, how long it is valid, the 30 day rule, the GIIN, and the managed company that is a financial institution.
- IRS, Form W-8BEN-E: the Active test in Part XXV, the Passive statements in Part XXVI, and the signature under penalties of perjury.
- IRS, Summary of key FATCA provisions: the 2010 law and what foreign financial institutions report.
- UAE Ministry of Finance, FATCA and CRS: the agreement with the USA of 17 June 2015, reporting through the Ministry, and Cabinet Resolution 93 of 2021 with the AED 20,000 fine.
- UAE Ministry of Finance, Guidance Notes for the Common Reporting Standard: the self-certification, Active NFE and Passive NFE, the investment entity test and controlling persons.